| John Wellman | 1960 | Brian Pohlman | 2003 |
| Richard Thompson | 1960 | Jason Bockey | 2003 |
| Rex Bowersock | 1960 | Matt Renner | 2003 |
| Charles Plikerd | 1968 | Dan Hemker | 2004 |
| Ron Kill | 1974 | Tom Theobald | 2004 |
| Jim Wellman | 1975 | Tony Bonifas | 2005 |
| Jim Friedrich | 1994 | Luke Smith | 2005 |
| Randy Pohlman | 1996 | Ashley Dilworth | 2005 |
| Joe Tucker | 2001 | Matt Kaverman | 2005 |
| Brandon Brenneman | 2001 | Chad Luersman | 2005 |
| Jeremy Ricker | 2001 | Cody Herman | 2006 |
| Jim Mox | 2002 | Kyle Rode | 2006 |
| Kyle Pohlman | 2002 | Todd Trentman | 2006 |
| Mike Hemker | 2002 | Micah Brentlinger | 2007 |
| Nolan Mericle | 2002 | Bryan Hoersten | 2007 |
| Jeremy Rahrig | 2002 | Brent Looser | 2007 |
| Cory Haehn | 2002 | Kristie Turner | 2007 |
| Brandyn Suever | 2002 | Zach Miller | 2007 |
| Lindsey Garza | 2003 | Alan Trentman | 2007 |