LIBERTY-BENTON LOCAL SCHOOLS
MONDAY NOVEMBER 20, 2006
BOARD OF EDUCATION OFFICE 9190 CO. RD. 9, FINDLAY OHIO
REGULAR BOARD OF EDUCATION MEETING 6:00 P.M.
STRATEGIC PLANNING WORK SESSION IMMEDIATELY FOLLOWING
I. Call to Order
Pledge of Allegiance ……………………………………………Jeff Shadle, Board President
II. Recognition of Visitors
III. Approval of minutes from the Monday, October 16, 2006 regular and special board of education meetings.
IV. Communications and Discussion
Regional School Improvement Team presentation by John Olds and Kathy Brickner
V. Principals’ Reports
Brian Burkett, Bruce Otley, Brenda Frankart
VI. Treasurer’s Report ………………………………………………………………Lisa Dobbins
VII. Superintendent’s Report ……………………………………………………….Dennis Recker
VIII. New Business
A. Approve Consent Agenda, to include:
1. Listing of bills, expenditures, and investments through 10/31/06, and monthly financial report of the Treasurer.
2. Approve appropriation modifications for November 2006
3. Approve the five year forecast and assumptions
4. Approve the listing of obsolete/disposed of inventory
5. Accept $6635.60 from NWO SERRC for the State Improvement Grant FY2007
6. Accept $2000 from the Liberty-Benton PTO for Camp Storer
7. Accept the following donation for the Dana Bowman Program: Findlay Tall Timbers Distribution/Ohio Logistics $1500, Rowmark $1500, Kiwanis Club $500, The Right Thing $400, Marathon $250
8. Approve agreement between the Liberty-Benton Local Schools and “The Architect” for architectural services for the auxiliary gym floor
9. Approve agreement between the Liberty-Benton Local Schools and “The Architect” for design services for the athletic complex
10. Approve the following “Then and Now” purchase orders:
PO #128640 to “The Architect”
PO #128641 to “The Architect”
PO #128687 to “Rahmberg Stover and Associates
PO #128713 to “Alltel”
11. Accept 1st and 2nd quarter EMIS FY07 subsidy payment in the amount of $1000 each
12. Accept 2006-07 Literacy Improvement Building Volunteer Coordinator Stipend in the amount of $2000 for OhioReads
13. Approve the following resignation:
Dawn Blankenship, junior class advisor effective November 10, 2006
14. Approve the following classified staff:
Janet Jones, increase to 6.25 per day, special education aide
Michelle Groves, Substitute
Melissa Holley, Substitute
Kim Cook, Substitute
Kristine Bartel, Substitute
Tami Karhoff, Substitute
15. Approve contract correction, Step 5 to Sue Stennett
16. Approve supplemental contract for Sarah Santilli, before school Choir instruction
17. Approve the following extra-curricular personnel for 2006-07 school year:
Dave Rath, Assistant Boys Basketball Coach
Jeff Kloepfer, Assistant Girls Basketball Coach
Ryan Lieb, Assistant Girls Basketball Coach
Marshal Headley, 8th grade Girls Basketball Coach
18. Approve the following certified long term substitutes:
Eileen Rucki
Claudia Benjamin
19. Approve transportation in lieu of for Deb Lussier, mother of Hannah, third grader at Trinity Lutheran School
B. Accept Kesha Brooks, daughter of Jason and Sarah Harper as tuition free student to complete her senior year
C. Accept Ashley Hughes, daughter of Cindy Hughes as tuition student for the 2006-07 school year
D. Approve Camp Storer Science Trip for 2007-08 school year
IX. Other Business
X. Executive Session
XI. Adjournment
LIBERTY-BENTON LOCAL SCHOOLS
NOVEMBER DISTRICT BOARD OF EDUCATION REPORT
DENNIS L. RECKER, SUPERINTENDENT
However, we’ve been able to find some interesting data points. 87% of our employees have primary care physicians. The remainder tend to self-refer to a specialist. While a national average of 47.7% of employees utilize preventive care, our consortium utilizes at a 38.4% rate.
One overarching factor which might be influencing cost is that 42% of the health care enrollees are aged 40 or greater, (25% are 50+) and our biggest “jump” of enrollees from 2005-2006 is the age group of 50 or greater. (Historically, teachers retired at age 51 or 52, but this has changed due to the reduction of STRS insurance coverage.)
The health consortium is not performing as expected due to:
· a significant increase in high cost claims due to unpreventable catastrophic claims
· an aging population with escalated chronic conditions, and a low use of preventative care services
· a high proportion of enrollees are Level III disease management patients
· our enrollees not using primary care physicians and moving to self-referred specialty care
Our last plan year, we had 5.4 million in health care expenses, covering 1656 enrollees, averaging $3305 per enrollee for the year. When we calculate an annual fee per enrollee to help “navigate” the system, the cost is $95 per year per enrollee.
Her results have been negotiated agreements with our unions that are fair to them and to us, the employer. She also avails herself to answer any questions, which are few and far between, stemming from the negotiated agreement, and has become our “go-to” counsel for employment related questions.
Again, for the 12th years I’ve been doing this, we see growth in student intelligence levels, higher predicted levels compiled, for the most part, with even higher actual grade equivalency.
This is “value added” we need to focus on because when I reviewed this we also got state 3rd grade reading results. The state assessment had us dead even with the state projection, yet we find ourselves 4 months ahead of our 3rd grade peers on the IOWA Test of Basic Skills.
This is not to belabor the point as to which instrument is more valid (The IOWA in case anyone asks), but to show that cross-referencing data might be a way to “check the facts” regarding student performance.
SAS (Group) 2004 2005 2006
3rd 94.2
4th 99.0 107.1
5th 97.4 102.9 105.3
Grade 3 N=106 Tested at Grade 3.2
Reading Predicted 2.9 Language Predicted 2.9 Math Predicted 2.9 Soc Stud Predicted 3.0
Reading Actual 3.7 Language Actual 3.1 Math Actual 3.3 Soc Stud Actual 4.0
Difference +0.8 Difference +0.2 Difference +0.4 Difference +1.0
Science Predicted 2.9 Source of Inform Predicted 3.0 Composite Predicted 2.9
Science Actual 4.0 Source of Inform Actual 3.6 Composite Actual 3.6
Difference +1.1 Difference +0.6 Predicted Difference +0.7
Chronological Difference +0.4
Grade 4 N=79 Tested at Grade 4.2
Reading Predicted 5.0 Language Predicted 5.2 Math Predicted 4.8 Soc Stud Predicted 5.0
Reading Actual 5.4 Language Actual 5.3 Math Actual 4.9 Soc Stud Actual 5.7
Difference +0.4 Difference +0.1 Difference +0.1 Difference +0.7
Science Predicted 5.2 Source of Inform Predicted 5.2 Composite Predicted 5.0
Science Actual 5.7 Source of Inform Actual 5.7 Composite Actual 5.5
Difference +0.5 Difference +0.5 Predicted Difference +0.5
Chronological Difference +1.3
Grade 5 N=102 Tested at Grade 5.2
Reading Predicted 6.0 Language Predicted 6.6 Math Predicted 5.8 Soc Stud Predicted 6.1
Reading Actual 6.3 Language Actual 6.5 Math Actual 5.6 Soc Stud Actual 7.0
Difference +0.3 Difference -0.1 Difference -0.2 Difference +0.9
Science Predicted 6.3 Source of Inform Predicted 6.1 Composite Predicted 6.1
Science Actual 6.8 Source of Inform Actual 6.6 Composite Actual 6.4
Difference +0.5 Difference +0.5 Predicted Difference +0.3
Chronological Difference +1.2
The last time we saw results like this was last school year.
ELEMENTARY PRINCIPAL’S REPORT
Liberty-Benton Board of Education
November 20, 2006
1. As of today, we have the following number of students in our elementary program:
Oct. 2006
Pre-school - 21 (1 section – ½ a.m. & ½ p.m.) ( 21)
Kindergarten - 97 (5 sections – avg. class 19.4) ( 99)
First Grade - 74 (4 sections – avg. class 18.5) ( 78)
Second Grade - 82 (4 sections – avg. class 20.5) ( 82)
Third Grade - 105 (5 sections – avg. class 21.0) (108)
Fourth Grade - 84 (4 sections – avg. class 21.0) ( 85)
Fifth Grade - 105 (5 sections – avg. class 21.0) (104)
(568 with pre-school)
2. Our Veteran’s Day event with Dana Bowman went extremely well. I believe he truly touched not only our students, but our staff as well. His message of remaining positive, focusing on your abilities (not what you can’t do), and what our Veterans have done and continue to do for our freedom was inspirational to say the least. I would like to thank Mr. Schimmoeller and our bus drivers for making the transportation for this event run so seamlessly. Additionally, the administration and staff of all buildings were wonderfully supportive of and flexible with the arrangements for this to be accomplished at McComb’s Auditorium. A large thank you also goes out to Mrs. Darlene Mack, McComb M.S. guidance counselor and McComb Schools for their partnership in this joint project! Our goal in providing this program was to raise the level of appreciation of our country’s veterans and for our community, teachers, and students to hear the inspirational message of Sgt. First Class Dana Bowman. For more information about Dana and his message, it is easily accessible from his website: www.danabowman.com.
3. Below is a breakdown of our 3rd Grade Reading Achievement Test results that we received this
past week:
Oct. 06 (106 tested) Oct. 05 (80 tested)
Advanced Level 19.0% (20 students) 27.5% (22 students)
Accelerated Level 19.0% (20 students) 15.0% (12 students)
Proficient Level 22.0% (23 students) 26.3% (21 students)
(Total Prof. or above:) 59.0% (62 students) 69.8% (55 students)
Basic Level 23.0% (24 students) 11.3% (9 students)
Limited Level 18.0% (19 students) 20.0% (16 students)
We are in the process of analyzing our school data, providing in-service on effective strategies,
interventions, and programs and collaborating to strengthen our program. We are currently working
with the Hancock County ESC curriculum supervisors, Northwest Ohio SERRC, and RSIT
(Regional School Improvement Team) from the Ohio Department of Education. Our last two year’s
(2004 & 2005) final 3rd grade Ohio Achievement tests in reading results were 84.9% and 85.7%
proficient or above respectively. We are committed to maintaining a high-level of achievement for
all students.
4. Attached you find a copy of our specials teachers’ (art, music, physical education, and computer)
1st quarter update. This went home with all students with their report cards to enhance
communication between our specials’ programs and our parents. I provide one for you as well so
you are aware of the fantastic educational opportunities are specials programs bring to our
students!
UPCOMING ELEMENTARY EVENTS:
Nov. 20 Parent Teacher Conferences 5:30 p.m.- 8:30 p.m.
Nov. 21 Parent Teacher Conferences 8:30 a.m.- 4:00 p.m.
Nov. 22-26 Thanksgiving Break – No School
Dec. 5 Scheduled 2-hour Delay
Dec. 7 Family Movie Night 7:00 p.m.
Dec.11-14 PTO Winter Book Fair all week
Dec. 13 Stevi B’s Night
Dec. 14 4th Grade Holiday Music Program 7:00 p.m.
Dec. 15 Elementary Interims (Mid-terms) go home
Dec. 18 Board Meeting 6:00 p.m.
MIDDLE SCHOOL PRINCIPAL’S REPORT
Liberty-Benton Board of Education
November 20, 2006
6:00 p.m.
1) Students of the Quarter Selected: The following students who were selected by their teachers as students of the quarter. These students will have their picture taken by Baker photography and will be treated to ice cream at Dietsch’s.
Eighth grader: Devin Harmon
Seventh grader: Marie Strasbaugh
Sixth grader: Nick Curto
2) Student Council Dance a Success: On November 3, 2006 students at Liberty-Benton Middle School enjoyed a fun filled evening at our fall dance. The dance was from 7:00-9:30 and was DJ’d by Liberty-Benton’s own Mr. Scoles. The kids and chaperones had a great time.
3) Limo Pizza Luncheon: Students that sold 10 magazines or more were treated to a limousine ride and pizza luncheon on Friday, October 27, 2006. Students cruised to Stevi B’s Pizza in either a stretch limo or stretch Hummer and enjoyed an all you can eat pizza buffet for about 1 hour. 78 students enjoyed the reward. A good time was had by all.
4) Midterms Dates:
Qtr. 2
– December 8
Qtr. 3 – February 23
Qtr. 4 – May 4
5) Grade Cards/End of the First 9 Weeks: The end of the grading period was Friday, November 3, 2006. It is hard to believe that the year is one quarter over! It has been a memorable fall and we are off to an excellent start. Grade cards will be mailed home Friday, November 10, 2006.
6) Parent-Teacher Conferences: The following are the scheduled conference times:
Thursday, November 16 @ 5:30-8:30
Monday, November 20 @ 5:30-8:30
Tuesday, November 21 @ 8:30-11:30 and 1:00-4:00
The Thursday evening conferences were well attended with 29 team conferences scheduled. I enjoyed speaking with parents and students.
7) National Junior Honors Society: The following twenty one students were inducted into the National Junior Honor Society on Tuesday, October 24, 2006 at 7:00 p.m. at Vanlue. Mrs. Amy Schroeder, NJHS Advisor, did a nice job recognizing these students for their accomplishments at the ceremony.
Taylor Allen Caitlin Mathias
Rebecca Birkhofer Warner Moses
Eric Bowsher Evan Nailborski
Paige Brodine Jared Peverly
Adrienne Ford Jenny Shadle
Austin Fox Josh Shaffer
Devin Harmon Brooke Stennett
Spenser Hoagland Louis Streacker
Alyssa Hunker Brandon Swope
Brett Koenig Chelsea Whikehart
Georgia Krebs
8) Current Enrollment:
Grade Total
06 103
07 92
08 91
Total Students: 286
9) Power Outage: Monday, November 13, 2006 was not a typical day in the district as a semi-truck knocked out a major power line. At approximately 9:45 all three buildings lost power. The initial report was that power would be restored in two hours. I collaborated with Mr. Burkett and Mr. Horstman to develop a plan of action. It was determined that lunch could be served. Middle school students were dismissed to the gym as most of our classrooms have no exterior windows and the majority of the building would be dark. Mr. Schoonover brought a generator in and we were able to watch a movie on the big screen in the gym while we waited for the power to be restored. The goal was to get students through lunch, during which time, power should be restored. Somewhere in the middle of lunch, it was learned that the power would be out for 5 hours.
The students and staff made the best out of an abnormal situation. In retrospect, some positive things can be drawn from the experience. We de-briefed as a staff on 11/15/06 and ideas were pooled
on how to be better prepared for similar situations should they arise in the future.
HIGH SCHOOL PRINCIPAL’S REPORT
Liberty-Benton Board of Education Meeting
November 20, 2006
6:00 P.M.
1.) Veterans’ Day Assembly - Thank you to Mr. Burkett for all of his hard work in securing the funding for the special Veterans’ Day assemblies with Dana Bowman. His message was quite meaningful and very professionally orchestrated.
2.) First Quarter Attendance - Our first nine weeks’ attendance rate overall was 97%.
3.) First Quarter Honor Roll - We had 220 students make the first nine weeks’ honor roll. The Academic Boosters treated honor roll students to our first quarter ice cream social on Friday, November 17, 2006. What a great way to end our week!
4.) Grade Card DASL Issues - We have experienced a DASL problem with our first nine weeks’ grade cards, but the problem does not effect all students. This is a problem in the software that the A-site programmers are currently working to fix. The students who have been effected are the students who had changed their schedule earlier this Fall. As a result, even though everything appears correctly on the grade card, the computer mistakenly thinks the students are in multiple sections of those courses, and the calculations being used then throws off the GPA listed for the nine weeks. Of course, the nine weeks’ GPA does not directly effect the cumulative GPA’s because these calculations come directly from the first semester averages. Other schools have also experienced the same problems with their DASL software. We can easily identify which students have been effected by this, or not, because the ones who are effected have an incorrect number of credits displayed at the bottom of the grade card when compared to the credits that are actually shown on the print-out. We have been explaining this to parents all week.
5.) National Honor Society Induction - Congratulations to the 36 LBHS students who were inducted into the Hancock County Chapter of the National Honor Society on November 6th, and special congratulations to Michael Shivers who was elected to serve as president of the group for this school year. This is a very nice honor, and Michael did a very nice job in delivering his campaign speech.
6.) Salvation Army Canned Food Drive - It is that time of year again when the can wars are on at the high school. Once again, some classes are being very competitive and working to add a lot of fun and interest into this worthy, annual service project. Thank you for Z-Club and Student Council for assisting in this joint venture. Our building goal this year is to collect 7,000 pounds of food. If we meet our goal, we will hold our annual Winter Fun Day activities on the afternoon of December 22nd before we leave for the break. This, too, is also a good motivational tool for a successful food drive.
7.) OSBA Conference Presentation & Student Achievement Fair - I would like to thank Joyce Jackson and Mike Scoles for assisting me with the OSBA Capital Conference presentation. Our presentation titled, “Developing a Sense of Belonging Through Leadership and Service,” was well attended for the very first session of the conference, and we received very complimentary ratings for our work. Also, I would like to thank two of our students, Chelsey Benjamin (sr.) and Monica Switzer (jr.) for joining us at the conference for the Tuesday Student Achievement Fair. These two ladies did an outstanding job of representing our high school and teaching the schools, superintendents, treasurers, school board members, and principals in attendance about the strengths and assets of our STRIDES program. We were very proud of being able to promote this program at the conference.
8.) Power Outage - Of course, the great power outage of November 13, 2006, had perfect timing by occurring in the middle of our OSBA presentation on Monday morning. We had been instructed to turn off our phones or put them on vibrate, and once our presentation was over, we could tell from the 20+ phone calls and text messages that there must be a problem back home. However, the operations back here were in complete confidence and handled so smoothly!!! Everyone pitched in and really handled things very well in our absence. I especially thank Mrs. Schimmoeller, Mrs. Metzger, Mr. Frommer, Mr. Horstman, Mr. Burkett, Mr. Otley, Mr. Butler, and Mr. Eckhart for all helping to cover the special needs of the day. Classes in the dark rooms were moved strategically. Flashlights were available for the bathrooms. Lunches were arranged quickly, and most instruction continued as usual. Way to go, team!
9.) Lockdown Drill - At the high school we held our best lockdown drill ever on November 10th. We had no violations to report for the procedures in our policy. The entire building was quietly in hiding in less than a minute, and our school resource officer filed an official report to document our drill.
10.) Fire Drill - Of course, our fire drill was a completely different story on November 1st. Our previous drills in September and October were fine, but now, none of the equipment is working in the A-Wing part of our building. Both the audible alarms and the strobes have malfunctioned. Until the alarms are repaired or replaced, we are using the manual system of air horns being sounded by teachers. We have four air horns in place in the four corners of the A-Wing for any emergency or drill that occurs.
11.) Relay For Life Update - The final decision was made at a November 4th meeting that the Hancock County Relay For Life event, which has repeatedly been held at Donnell Stadium on the same days as our LBHS Relay For Life, is now moving out here to combine with our Relay. Our STRIDES program is really excited about this joint venture, and we are looking forward to this year’s Hancock County Relay For Life. Joyce Jackson and I are co-chairing the event along with a teacher from McComb High School, Maggie Hendrix. We are planning on working to involve much more of the community in this year’s event. The Relay will be held on the same weekend, which is May 18-19, 2007. Mark your calendars.
12.) Upcoming Events:
Nov. 20 Parent-Teacher Conferences, 5:30-8:30
Nov. 21 Parent-Teacher Conferences, 8:30-11:30 & 1:00-4:00
Nov. 22 Stevi B’s Pizza Night
Nov. 22-24 Thanksgiving Break
Nov. 29 & Dec. 1 Winter Play, “A Little Christmas Spirit,” 7:00 p.m.
Dec. 5 Two-Hour Collaboration
Dec. 9 Student Council Winter Dance, LBHS students only, 8-11:00
Dec. 12 Holiday Concert, 7:30